Your Cards. Hand Delivered to PSA.
PSA Authorized Card Grading Submission Service - San Diego
SUBMISSION SERVICES
WHITE GLOVE SERVICES
Pre Evaluation of your cards before it's sent off to grading.
Learn how we can streamline your process with our Submission Services Nostalgic Avenue offers two service levels that help you get your raw cards into graded slabs.
Now on the App Store
Shop graded cards, run PSA submissions, and manage your collection from your iPhone, synced with your Nostalgic Avenue account. Learn more about the app.
Complete Submission Services
Authorized PSA Dealer
Every service we offer is centered on one purpose: protect your cards, protect your wallet, and maximize every PSA submission. Whether you simply need expert prep or want full strategic evaluation, we handle the entire journey by hand, including direct delivery to PSA Headquarters.
Prefer to talk it through? Schedule a consultation.
Send ALL Service
Our foundational prep program for collectors who want every card packed to PSA specs without the full evaluation stack. We prep, organize, and hand deliver so you never worry about shipping risks.
Start a Send ALL intake $7 Per Card*Service fee excludes PSA grading costs. PSA fees for Send ALL are collected during checkout.
White Glove Service
Our signature concierge experience blends deep inspection, transparent scoring, and strategy recommendations so you only spend PSA fees on cards that deserve it.
Start a White Glove intake $15 Per Card*Service fee excludes PSA grading costs. PSA fees are billed separately once you approve the final submission list.
Why Choose Nostalgic Avenue
We evaluate all types of cards with precision and care. Our process is easy and simple, designed to maximize your submission success while protecting your investment.
View All ServicesSend Your Cards
Ship your raw cards to us securely. We handle everything from intake to final delivery.
We Evaluate
Professional inspection and scoring ensures only quality cards move forward to grading.
Send to Grading
We personally hand-deliver your submission to PSA Headquarters for maximum security.
Ship Back to You
Once graded, we receive, verify, and securely ship your slabs back to you.
The Grading Companies
We submit cards with PSA, BGS, and SGC several times per week to keep your cards moving in an effort to get them back to you as quick as possible.
Our Testimonials
Nostalgic helped me analyze my cards with confidence. I trusted their recommendation to roll the dice.
They really make sure you're not sending in duds.
The online selection was really easy. They got this process down.
I'm sending all my cards to Nostalgic.
I sent them over 1000 cards. Thought that it would be too much for them to evaluate. I was wrong.
Featured Products
Discover our latest graded cards and collectibles
2018 Pokemon Japanese Sun & Moon Ultra Shiny Gx Glaceon Gx Mint 9
$20.00
2021 Pokemon Japanese Sword & Shield Blue Sky Stream Fa/gyarados Vmax Mint 9
$15.00
2018 Pokemon Japanese Sun & Moon Ultra Shiny Gx Greninja Gx Mint 9
$20.00
2023 Pokemon Japanese Sv2a-pokemon 151 Mr. Mime Mint 9
$15.00